A woman who sought over $100,000 in damages after she slipped in a Coles supermarket has instead been granted only $880.

Leslie Fitzsimmons sued Coles Supermarket after she slipped while shopping at a Gosford store on the NSW Central Coast in December 2009.

Ms Fitzsimmons claimed she suffered injuries to her ankle and back after she slipped on a wet floor while trying to find a birthday cake.

She took the case to the NSW District Court last year, but it was dismissed and she was ordered to pay costs.

Judge Elizabeth Olsson found Ms Fitzsimmons had failed to establish Coles was in breach of its duty of care.

The supermarket had taken precautions to warn customers of the slippery condition of the floor by placing three signs around it, the court heard.

Ms Fitzsimmons said she was hurrying through the store with her daughter on her hip and that she didn't see the signs.

There was also some evidence she was arguing with her boyfriend at the time, although how that affected her falling was not clear, the court heard.

Judge Olsson expressed concern about the "many troubling aspects" of Ms Fitzsimmons' evidence, noting her appearance in the witness box was at odds with what she had told Centrelink and her physiotherapist about her injuries.

"There is a degree of exaggeration by (Ms Fitzsimmons) of her symptoms, particularly when she was presenting to various medical practitioners," the judge concluded.

Ms Fitzsimmons appealed this decision in the Court of Appeal and asserted her claim was worth "many times more than the sum of $100,000".

The appeal court allowed the appeal but ordered Ms Fitzsimmons should receive just $886.50 in damages.

She was also ordered to pay Coles' legal costs.

"By no stretch of imagination could this be regarded as success on the appeal," the judgment said.

The decision comes just weeks after a Sydney woman, Charlene Meneghello, who slipped in a Neutral Bay Coles store, had her award of $120,000 revoked on appeal.

A third woman, Rennie Kissun, was awarded over $170,000 in damages by the District Court earlier this month after she slipped in a Castle Hill Coles supermarket.

About News.net

Publishing Services International Limited (PSIL) is the publisher and operator of a worldwide network of online news sites dedicated to delivering fair, accurate and relevant reporting from a variety of the world’s most trusted sources – from the biggest cities to the smallest towns.

We deliver positive and powerful messages to our readers, providing up‑to‑the‑second news that matters to the individual.

Our promise is to serve communities and individuals worldwide, delivering information that hasn’t always been available to them. We will give them back a voice – a voice that’s empowering because it is theirs – and provide a platform to communicate between themselves and the world.

We believe people are not just generic demographics; they are individuals with their own preferences and curiosities. We are about understanding these individuals, listening to them, and serving them.

We are the new pioneering spirit of news – we’re not talking to everyone, we’re talking with every one.

If you want your news, your voice, your way, on your time – we’ve got news for you.

 

FAQs

Email

If you have any questions or concerns please email us on support@news.net

Phone

  • Australia, Toll Free 1-800-983-421
  • Hong Kong, Toll Free 800-906-187
  • Singapore, Toll Free 800-852-3871
  • USA/Canada, Toll Free 1-800-830-4132

Advertise With Us

Interested in being awesome?
Contact us by email or phone.

Cancel